Score: 6

"Decent"

submission: M.P.S.R

date: March 3, 2009

It's decent, but you need a heavier rhythm and more guitar before this even becomes metal. Also, the music is very choppy, reduce that, and it'll make a huge difference in the ratings. 6/10.

Score: 8

"Nice"

submission: Through the Desert:Rain

date: March 3, 2009

Nice song, would have been better if it didn't have the hum and feedback. Overall, it's striking me as about an 8.

Score: 10

"Great song."

submission: Final Redemption

date: March 3, 2009

This is definitely one of my favorite songs on here. Has a nice rhythm, the genre doesn't fully strike me as heavy metal, as it's not as heavy or intense, but this is definitely a metal genre of some sort. Does have a hint of DragonForce to it though, which strike off as power metal. It's not overpowering though to make it power metal. Don't know what it is, but I like it.

Score: 8

"Nice, but....."

submission: FF6 - Decisive battle (Metal)

date: February 3, 2009

Seems a bit techno to me. Tone down on the Keyboard/Synthesizer a bit, and it'll stand out as metal, but the keyboard/synthesizer seems a bit overpowering to call this true heavy metal.

Score: 10

"rock on!"

submission: Disrepute

date: February 3, 2009

Rock on. You have the perfect Metal rhythm, lots of drums and heavy guitar rifts. The only thing to make it better are vocals, but seeing as not everyone can find a singer to match their band, I can't hold that against you. I'll defiantly give you top marks for this wonderful piece of art presented to the world.

Score: 9

"Great Music."

submission: Cry of War { Ambient Metal }

date: February 3, 2009

Great Music. Nice rhythm, smooth notes. As it's in the metal genre, it could use a bit more guitar and drum, but you defiantly have the ambient section down. It's a great song over all, and I give you a 9/10, 4/5.